Evaluation

 

Evaluation


Progress Report on Supporting Local Development in the Chittagong Hill Tracts

2014 | UNDP
Henrik F. Larsen

A Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) Peace Accord signed in December 1997 ended the decades-long insurgency, allowing for the recognition of the rights of the peoples…


Risk-Averse to Risk-Willing: Learning from the 2011 Somalia Cash Response

2012 | Global Food Security
Degan Ali and Kirsten Gelsdorf

In 2011 the humanitarian community faced a difficult question. Could large-scale cash transfers provide an effective alternative to food aid delivery in South Central Somalia…


Pioneers of Peace, Implementers of Humanitarianism: Learning from the Ambivalence of Peacebuilders

2020 | Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding
Lise Philipsen

This article nuances the popular explanation that peace interventions fail because of a culture of peacebuilders unwilling to engage with the local. As a foundational…


Peacebuilding and Development Trainings: What's Not Working and What We Should Be Doing Instead

2019 | Journal of Peacebuilding & Development
Elizabeth McClintock and Aline Brachet

Peacebuilding and development are two sides of the same coin yet integrating the two processes remains an ongoing challenge. One tool for achieving such integration…


Peace With Strings Attached: Exploring Reflections of Structure and Agency in Northern Ireland Peacebuilding Funding

2013 | Peacebuilding
Patlee Creary and Sean Bryne

This article examines Northern Ireland's peacebuilding process by analysing perspectives about economic assistance to determine if the peacebuilding process contributed to the reification of structure…


Peace and Conflict Impact Assessment (PCIA) in Community Development: A Case Study from Mozambique

2010 | Evaluation
Lisa Bornstein

Peace and conflict impact assessment (PCIA) is a tool that potentially can improve the quality of development work in conflict zones. PCIA’s conceptual strengths and…


Pcia Theory in Field Practice: World Vision's Pursuit of Peace Impact and Programming Quality Across Sectors

2014 | Journal of Peacebuilding & Development
Valarie V Kamatsiko

This article provides a critical reflection of World Vision’s field practice with Peace and Conflict Impact Assessment (PCIA) related frameworks drawing from experiences in Kenya,…


Participatory Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation of Multi-Stakeholder Platforms in Integrated Landscape Initiatives

2017 | Environmental Management
Koen Kusters, Louise Buck, Maartje de Graaf, Peter Minang, Cora van Oosten, and Roderick Zagt

Integrated landscape initiatives typically aim to strengthen landscape governance by developing and facilitating multi-stakeholder platforms. These are institutional coordination mechanisms that enable discussions, negotiations, and…


Participatory Evaluation of Collaborative and Integrated Water Management: Insights from the Field

2007 | Journal of Environmental Planning and Management
Cecilia Ferreyra and Phil Beard

The Maitland Watershed Partnerships (MWPs) is a multi-stakeholder forum established in 1999 in an agricultural watershed in Southwestern Ontario, Canada. This paper presents 10 lessons…


Negotiating in a Coordination Network of Citizen Peacebuilding Initiatives in the Georgian-Abkhaz Peace Process

2006 | International Negotiation (Hague, Netherlands)
Sus A. Nan and Paula Garb

This article analyzes a set of negotiations within a coordination network. These negotiations surrounded the establishment and development of a coordination network of citizen peacebuilding…


Land in Return, Reintegration, and Recovery Processes: Some Lessons From The Great Lakes Region of Africa

2009 | Humanitarian Policy Group
Christopher D. Huggins

The chapter describes some of the political challenges involved in managing the transition from emergency activities to longer-term 'developmental' policies in Rwanda and Burundi. In…


Land and Conflict: A Toolkit for Intervention

2005 | USAID
David Bledsoe and Michael Brown

The purpose of this toolkit is to provide a practical introduction to the relationship between land and violent conflict. The relationship is stark, whether we…


Mitigating the Environmental Impacts of Post-Conflict Assistance: Assessing USAID's Approach

2012 | Earthscan from Routledge
Charles Kelly

When a country emerges from violent conflict, the management of the environment and natural resources has important implications for short-term peacebuilding and long-term stability, particularly…


Landmines and Livelihoods in Afghanistan: Evaluating the Benefits of Mine Action

2013 | Journal of Peacebuilding & Development
Ted Paterson, Barry Pound, and Abdul Q. Ziaee

Mine action started in Afghanistan and, globally, has grown into a billion-dollar endeavour. On most measures, Afghanistan remains the world’s largest mine action programme, which…


Food Security in Protracted Crises: Building More Effective Policy Frameworks

2005 | Disasters
Margarita Flores, Yasmeen Khwaja, and Philip White

This paper considers the principal elements that underpin policy frameworks for supporting food security in protracted crisis contexts. It argues that maintaining the food entitlements…


Mapping the Field of International Peace Education Programs and Exploring Their Networked Impact on Peacebuilding

2019 | Resolution Quarterly
Jeffrey Pugh and Karen Ross

Conventional wisdom holds that international education builds cross-cultural capacity, and evaluations of peacebuilding interventions point to significant impacts. Yet, little scholarship links these fields or…


Making the Case for Systematic, Gender-Based Analysis in Sustainable Peace Buidling

2016 | Conflict Resolution Quarterly
Dennis Sandole and Ingrid Staroste

In this article, we address protracted, often recurring violent conflict, arguing that the failure to solve entrenched conflicts and build sustainable peace is due in…


Mainstreaming Failure or a Small Measure of Success? Observations from a Large-Scale PCIA in Post-War Sri Lanka

2014 | Journal of Peacebuilding & Development
Simona Achitei

In May 2009, controversies emerged over Sri Lanka’s human rights record in the last stages of the 27-year civil war between the Government of Sri…


Looking Back, Moving Forward: International Approaches to Addressing Conflict-Related Sexual Violence

2012 | Journal of Women, Politics & Policy
Lesley Pruitt

Based on a review of existing literature, this article provides an initial analysis of obstacles to addressing impunity for widespread conflict-related sexual violence. First, a…


Learning from Change: Issues and Experiences in Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation

2000 | Intermediate Technology Publications Ltd.
Marisol Estrella, Jutta Blauert, Dindo Campilan, John Gaventa,Julian Gonsalves, Irene Guijt, Deb Johnson, and Roger Ricafort

This book is a collection of experiences in participatory monitoring and evaluation (PM&E) from around the world. It allows different ‘voices’ to tell their story from…


Improving Peacebuilding Evaluation: A Whole-of-Field Approach

2011 | United States Institute of Peace
Andrew Blum

In May 2010, the Alliance for Peacebuilding in collaboration with the United States Institute of Peace launched the Peacebuilding Evaluation Project. Over the course of…


Human Rights Education in Peacebuilding: A Look at How Far the Practice Has Come and Where it Needs to Head

2010 | Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Rights Law
Tracey Holland

The world’s peace-building and development organizations increasingly are incorporating human-rights frameworks into the myriad of activities now under their purview. Slower to develop, however, are…


How Can Research Contribute to Peacebuilding?

2014 | University of York
Kenneth Bush and Colleen Duggan

How do we know whether or not research contributes to peacebuilding? And, what kind of positive or negative impacts may research have? These two questions…


Help or Hinrance? Results-Orientation in Conflict-Affected Situations

2013 | Swiss Peace
Stefan Bachtold, Roland Dittli, and Sylvia Servaes

Results-orientation, impact assessment, and value for money have been creating a growing buzz in the fields of international cooperation and peacebuilding for the last few…


Theory of Change Approach to Climate Change Adaptation Programming

2014 | UKCIP
Dennis Bours, Colleen McGinn, and Patrick Pringle

In this Guidance Note, we describe the Theory of Change approach and explain why it is a good fit for climate change adaptation programming. We…


Gaps in Knowledge About Local Peacebuilding: A Study in Deficiency from Jos, Nigeria

2020 | Third World Quarterly
Reina C. Neufeldt, Mary L. Klassen, John Danboyi, Jessica Dyck, and Mugu Z. Bako

The emphasis on local or hybrid efforts in peacebuilding literature brings front and centre the importance of being rooted within a particular context, with leadership…


Forested Landscapes for Equity: End Evaluation Report

2020 | Wageningen Centre for Development Innovation
Dieuwke Klaver, Hermine ten Hove, Jan Brouwers, Bram De Groote, and Jarl Kampen

This report presents the End Evaluation of the Forested Landscapes for Equity Programme, as implemented by the Green Livelihoods Alliance (GLA) over the period 2016-2020.…


Examining the Role of WASH Services Within Peace- and Statebuilding Processes

2012 | Tearfund
Leni WIld and Nathaniel Mason

This synthesis report presents the findings of a one-year research project funded by the Department for International Development (DFID) and implemented by Tearfund and ODI,…


Disaster Risk Reduction and Protracted Violent Conflict

2019 | German Federal Ministry of Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) and the Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
Rodrigo Mena, Dorothea Hilhorst, and Katie Peters

This report is part of the project ‘When disasters and conflict collide: uncovering the truth’, a collaboration between the German Federal Ministry of Economic Cooperation…


Conflict Sensitivity and Conservation: Evaluating Design, Implementation & Practice

2018 | Kennesaw State University
Amanda S. Woomer

This dissertation investigates the use of a conflict sensitivity framework in supporting environmental conservation work. Employing an action research methodology, it consists of a multi-phase…